Photobucket

12/16/2007

Download a Free Trial Copy of NCSS. Comprehensive and User-Friendly. Integrated Excel Add-In Statistical tests and diagrams

12/18/2007

Over 50 years of accurate, speedy, and affordable metal analysis. Dedicated Analytical Solutions for chemical analysis from Foss

12/16/2007

Mini-Gold spot trading, 24 hour 200:1 leverage, No Commissions. Two "Backdoor" Plays Ready to Soar. Get Your Free Investment Report.

12/16/2007

Ironman punya keunikan dalam warna dan tampilan. Beda dengan Robocop jauh lebih canggih dan lebih berfantasy... Saya mau koleksi…

12/14/2007

Gambar 1/2 manusia 1/2 kucing ditambah tatoo diseluruh badan menjadikan dia benar-benar 1/2 gila. Gigi manusia ini sudah berbentuk…

12/14/2007

Coba tebak berapa ukuran babi raksasa ini? berapa kilogram beratnya? Ukuran kepalanya saja mungkin sudah seberat 5 manusia. Babi…

12/18/2007

Serangan Jantung dan kebiasaan Minum Air Panas / hangat.... Artikel ini berguna untuk semua. Bukan saja anjuran meminum air…

12/16/2007

Foto wanita tercantik tercantik sejagat planet dan woowww... coba perhatikan!!.. Tapi kenyataannya dia memang menang dalam kompetisi.. Woow... So cute…

12/16/2007

Artis sinetron punya keunikan dalam warna dan tampilan. Beda dengan penyanyi jauh lebih canggih dan lebih berfantasy... Saya mau koleksi…

12/16/2007

Gambar atau foto ini adalah gambar helm Ironman dalam versi 3D. Film akan diputar pada pertengahan tahun depan (2008).…

12/14/2007

Gambar 1/2 manusia 1/2 kucing ditambah tatoo diseluruh badan menjadikan dia benar-benar 1/2 gila. Gigi manusia ini sudah berbentuk…

12/14/2007

Coba tebak berapa ukuran babi raksasa ini? berapa kilogram beratnya? Ukuran kepalanya saja mungkin sudah seberat 5 manusia. Babi…

12/18/2007

Serangan panas dan sembriwing.... Artikel ini berguna untuk semua. Bukan saja anjuran meminum air…

12/16/2007

Gambar cewe tercantik sejagat Asia Raya menurut saya sih.. Tapi kenyataannya dia memang menang dalam kompetisi.. Woow... So cute…

12/16/2007

Ironman punya keunikan dalam warna dan tampilan. Beda dengan Robocop jauh lebih canggih dan lebih berfantasy... Saya mau koleksi…

12/16/2007

Gambar atau foto ini adalah gambar helm Ironman dalam versi 3D. Film akan diputar pada pertengahan tahun depan (2008).…

12/14/2007

Gambar 1/2 manusia 1/2 kucing ditambah tatoo diseluruh badan menjadikan dia benar-benar 1/2 gila. Gigi manusia ini sudah berbentuk…

12/14/2007

Coba tebak berapa ukuran babi raksasa ini? berapa kilogram beratnya? Ukuran kepalanya saja mungkin sudah seberat 5 manusia. Babi…

12/18/2007

Serangan Jantung dan kebiasaan Minum Air Panas / hangat.... Artikel ini berguna untuk semua. Bukan saja anjuran meminum air…

12/16/2007

Gambar cewe tercantik sejagat Asia Raya menurut saya sih.. Hot..hot.. wow..wow... gila..busett.... Woow... So cute…

12/16/2007

Fantastic 4 punya keunikan dalam warna dan tampilan. Beda dengan girl powernya fs jauh lebih canggih dan lebih berfantasy... Saya mau koleksi…

12/16/2007

Gambar atau foto ini adalah gambar helm Ironman dalam versi 3D. Film akan diputar pada pertengahan tahun depan (2008).…

12/14/2007

Gambar 1/2 manusia 1/2 kucing ditambah tatoo diseluruh badan menjadikan dia benar-benar 1/2 gila. Gigi manusia ini sudah berbentuk…

12/14/2007

Coba tebak berapa ukuran babi raksasa ini? berapa kilogram beratnya? Ukuran kepalanya saja mungkin sudah seberat 5 manusia. Babi…

Rabu, 16 Januari 2008

{Brainstormers -CA} Re: Tax audit--Clubbing of Receipts from Bus. and Prof.

Hi Mr Agarwal and Abhishek,

This issue—-about the requirement for tax audit in case of business
sales of say Rs 36 lacs professional receipts of say Rs 8 lacs---did
cross my mind while I was penning down---typing out to be precise!---
my earlier reply. But I didn't touch upon it and restricted my reply
to specifically what Anjana Behanji had asked.

Although from a layman perspective, "business" and "profession" are
two sides of the same coin and are used interchangeably, in the
Income Tax Act these two terms have been used in a mutually
exclusive sense. So even though the inclusive definition of Business
u/s 2(13) as "any adventure or concern IN THE NATURE of trade,
commerce or manufacture" would seem to embrace a Profession as well,
in view of the separate definition of "profession" u/s 2(36), it is
clear the law intends to treat Business and Profession as two
different animals.

So a doctor has receipts of Rs 8 lacs from treating patients; he
also has a business of selling garments sales of which are Rs 36
lacs. Would he be required to get his accounts audited?

The Guidance Note on Tax Audit u/s 44AB issued by the ICAI
fortunately comes to our rescue. I am quoting below para 5.14 of the
Guidance Note:

[5.14. A question may arise in the case of an assessee carrying on
business and at the same time engaged in a profession as to what are
the limits applicable to him under section 44AB for getting the
accounts audited. In such a case if his professional receipts are,
say, rupees twelve lakhs but his total sales, turnover or gross
receipts in business are, say, rupees twenty two lakhs, it will be
necessary for him to get his accounts of the profession and also the
accounts of the business audited because the gross receipts from the
profession exceed the limit of rupees ten lakhs. If however, the
professional receipts are, say, rupees seven lakhs and total sales
turnover or gross receipts from business are, say, rupees thirty
four lakhs it will not be necessary for him to get his accounts
audited under the above section, because his gross receipts from the
profession as well as total sales, turnover or gross receipts from
the business are below the prescribed limits.]

So it's clear then. Unless the receipts/sales/turnover from the
individual component of business/professional activities exceed Rs
10 lacs or Rs 40 lacs, no tax audit would be required. Professional
receipts of Rs 12 lacs and business sales of Rs 22 lacs tots up to
Rs 34 lacs. But still, says the Guidance Note, the assessee needs to
get the accounts of not only his profession but also his business
audited. By implication, if the sales of business are Rs 40.10 lacs
and receipts from profession are Rs 2 lacs, the accounts of the
profession too would need to be put under the CA's scanner. On the
other hand, if sales from business are Rs 39.99 lacs and receipts
from profession are Rs 9.99 lacs, then the assessee can go scot-
free.

But respectfully, I partly disagree with this interpretation of
Section 44AB by the ICAI. From what I understand of the big idea
behind the introduction of this section, I think tax audit would be
called for even where the aggregate receipts from two separate and
distinct activities of business and profession exceed Rs 40 lacs.
The distinction between "business" and "profession" laid down in the
Act seems more academic than real. As far as the tax assessment is
concerned, both business and profession are assessed under the same
head of income. So if the idea is to rope in assessees whose incomes
exceed a certain level, it doesn't make any sense to let go of the
assessees whose gross receipts from the twin-activities of business
and profession cross Rs 40 lacs, but the individual receipts of
either of the two activities is below Rs 10 lacs/ Rs 40 lacs. But
this is what the ICAI is saying above.

As far for the VAT part, in Punjab there's no legal requirement to
apply for only one registration when you carry on two different
businesses at two different places.

Thanks,

CA Sanjeev Bedi

--- In ICAI_CIRC_MEERUT_CA@yahoogroups.com, "CA J P Agarwal"
<jp.jpaca@...> wrote:
>

> Dear Sanjeev Bhai,
>
> I would like to have your opinion when the professional income is
say Rs 5
> lacs and business (other than profession) is Rs 36 lacs (which
probably the
> members who wrought earlier intended to ask) would audit u/s 44AB
be
> attracted
>
> Further, I would like to add that as far as I understand even
under VAT (UP
> Trade tax) for different businesses owned by one assessee single
> registartion is required. If it is otherwise please apprise.
>
> CA J P AGARWAL
>
>
> Hi Anjana and others,
>
> I don't know what the big issue is about. Section 44AB speaks of
> turnover "in" business and not "of a" business. The use of the
> preposition "in" rather than the words "of a" leaves little room
for
> doubt that for the purposes of tax audit, the turnover from various
> businesses carried on by a person is to be aggregated; and if this
> figure exceeds Rs 40 lacs, each constituent business will be
> subjected to tax audit.
>
> The Rajasthan High Court has had an occasion to dissect Section
44AB
> recently in the case of Bajrang Oil Mills v. ITO [2007] 163 TAXMAN
> 154 (Raj.). Although the matter before the court had more to do
with
> the interpretation of seemingly synonymous
words "sales", "turnover"
> and "gross receipts" used in Section 44AB, the judgement clearly
> betrays what would have been the decision of the court had this
> multiple-business issue we are discussing come up before it.
>
> The court held that the maximum limit of Rs. 40 lacs in section
44AB
> has been fixed in the case of EVERY PERSON who is carrying on
> business and whose total receipts from the business activity, which
> come under the head "Income from profits and gains of business",
> have to be viewed as ONE INTEGRATED WHOLE and NOT INDEPENDENTLY.
The
> assessment of a person is on the total income and not on the income
> derived from the different sources separately.
>
> Also what about depreciation u/s 32? Would you add up the WDV of
> different asset blocks employed in different businesses? Suppose a
> proprietor owns two businesses--A and B. Machinery in Business A
has
> a WDV of Rs 100 and the machinery in Business B stands at a WDV of
> Rs 70; the machinery of Business B is sold for Rs 110, how would
you
> deal with it?
>
> In this situation, what we'll do is prepare only one Dep Chart for
> both businesses for Income Tax purpose. So the total closing
> machinery WDV will stand at Rs 60 (170-110). Those who advocate
that
> sales figure of each individual business be looked at independently
> for tax audit would also now have to take a stand that WDV of
> Business A would keep standing at Rs 100, while we shall compute an
> STCG of Rs 40 (110-70) in Business B. Would that be right? This
> would be palpably wrong, as a reading of Section 32 would
> reveal. "Used for the purpose of the business" as mentioned in
> Section 32 envisages the aggregate WDV of the different assets
> falling within the same block of assets even if deployed in
> different businesses. Definition of "block of assets" u/s 2(11) too
> underscores that the "block" concept would straddle over all
> businesses of an assessee; a sale of an asset in one business may
> impact the WDV of that class of assets in the other business. So
> we'd need to prepare only IT Dep Chart to arrive at correct
> depreciation/STCG/WDV.
>
> A perusal of the CBDT circular No 387 dated 06.07.1984 also clearly
> brings out the intention of the legislature. The idea behind tax
> audit was to assist the AO to determine the taxable income of the
> ASSESSEE, by requiring certain "big" assessees to have their books
> of account audited. It would be puerile to think that an assessee
> having a single business with turnover of Rs 1 crore is a "big"
> assessee; while another one having five different businesses with
> sales of Rs 20 lacs each is a "small" assessee. If indeed such a
> plea were to be accepted, there would be a huge deluge of
> unscrupulous assessees springing up overnight who would obtain five
> different VAT registrations with different trade names and refuse
to
> go under the 44AB scalpel on the grounds that the turnover in none
> of their businesses is beyond Rs 40 lacs!
>
> Sat Sri Akal,
>
> CA Sanjeev Bedi
>
>
> --- In ICAI_CIRC_MEERUT_CA@yahoogroups.com, "rani girdhar"
> <ranigirdhar@> wrote:
> >
> > IN MY OPINION TAX AUDIT IS NOT REQUIRED BECAUSE BOTH THE
> CONDITIONS OF U/S 44A ARE NOT SATISFIED.WHEN ACT DIFINES TWO
> DIFFERENT NORMS FOR BUSINESS AND PROFESSION THEN WHY WE COMBINED
> THEM.
> >
> >
> > On Mon, 14 Jan 2008 saurabh garg wrote :
> > >I my openion Tax audit is required.
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >On 1/12/08, ranjana mahajan <ran347@> wrote:
> > > >
> > > > i have 5 different business with different set of
> books , having
> > > > turnover of 20 lakhs plus in each business, but less than 40
> lakhs in each
> > > > of the individual business, dou think i dont need my
> accounts to be
> > > > audited u/s 44AB
> > > >
> > > > thnkx
>
>
>
>
>
>

__._,_.___
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT INDIA AMRESH VASHISHT, DISCLAIMER
"The answer(s)/advice(s) on this Group web-site are the personal opinions of the members who sent those messages. They may/or may not be based on  research(s)/opinion(s) on the fact(s) provided to the Group in the said  query, and any advice tendered here is subject to the accuracy of the  description of facts, proposed transactions, and their purpose and
whether they constitute a complete and accurate disclosure of all
relevant fact(s), and provided the proposed transaction(s) is completed
in the stated manner. The Group Owner/Moderator and/or the group
member(s) do not even imply the accuracy or value of any advice
submitted by its member(s) and are not liable for any damages or costs,
if any, suffered through the acceptance or putting into operation either
the whole or part of any advice so tendered on the group-site. If you
have any question(s), please do not hesitate to seek clarification(s)
Here"
Recent Activity
Visit Your Group
Yahoo! Finance

It's Now Personal

Guides, news,

advice & more.

New business?

Get new customers.

List your web site

in Yahoo! Search.

Featured Y! Groups

and category pages.

There is something

for everyone.

.

__,_._,___

Tidak ada komentar: